game Xbox 360 » ECW Box Cover
views 2,336   favorites 1 (?)  


ECW box art cover
By avatar Mr.Fantastic09 1 on October 3rd, 2008
print No Printable Available

[ Box updated on October 4th, 2008 ] [ original ]

comments ECW Box Cover Comments


Comment on Mr.Fantastic09's ECW Box Art / Cover.

avatar
Mr.Fantastic09 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

ecw: extreme championship wrestling.

my first wrestling box. tell me what you think.

[ Reply ]


avatar
Mr.Fantastic09 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

come on ppl my boxes never get commentedd!

[ Reply ]


avatar
tleeart 45 [ 1 decade ago ]

You can get banned for "bumping" your box and begging for comments.

You want a comment, here you go:

-Your logo is blurry
-C.M. Punk is badly stretched
-I don't know what that is behind Punk's head
-the background image is okay, but shouldn't be repeated in the exact same fashion as it is on the box
-the THQ logo and the rating logo is stretched and the rating logo is altogether too small
-I would use M rating or T rating for an ECW game, based on how much violence found within
-I don't like that XB360 template

Okay, thats what I have to say about that.

[ Reply ]


avatar
Mr.Fantastic09 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

ok well u can get banned for that


u only pointed out the bad things


its called constructive critiscm

[ Reply ]


avatar
tleeart 45 [ 1 decade ago ]

#4, If I just told you it sucked, that wouldn't be constructive criticism. I pointed out things that should be fixed and I did say I like the red background image. Also, if you want to talk about getting banned, you should also use proper grammar such as spelling out you instead of using u.

If you don't like my comment, that's fine, but you shouldn't threaten me when you have no grounds for me to be banned.

In another constructive criticism, I do like that you used C.M. Punk, but I would use a picture not depicting him as champion, as the wrestling titles can change hands at any time.

[ Reply ]


avatar
gamerking 43 [ 1 decade ago ]

lol at #4. anyway...it's not that great. sorry. and why is the rp so skinny?

[ Reply ]


avatar
rod 5 [ 1 decade ago ]

well i think it's okay except that the background is blended in with the outside of the template but other than that i like it

[ Reply ]


avatar
Drakxxx 46 [ 1 decade ago ]

Well to be fair #4 a criticism doesn't necessarily have to mention the subjects good qualities, especially if the person critiquing isn't seeing any.

He did mention that the background was ok.:)

The composition is decent, but the box is to small and blurry. try working around 300 dpi, and as always, try to work with an art application other than Microsoft Paint.

[ Reply ]


avatar
Mr.Fantastic09 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

heres an updated version. i think this is better than before.

credit to CrayonMan for the template

[ Reply ]


avatar
gamerking 43 [ 1 decade ago ]

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better. lol.

[ Reply ]


avatar
Mr.Fantastic09 1 [ 1 decade ago ]

aha thanks..you still didnt see my latest art..coming later tonightt.

[ Reply ]


avatar
tleeart 45 [ 1 decade ago ]

Ah, I'm glad I came back to this. Still a tad blurry, You might want to actually bump down the resolution, especially since it seems this isn't meant for print. The new render of Punk is a lot better, though I would brighten him up a tad so he can stand out more.

Wow, I don't mean to nag this time, just a couple things that can make this stronger. 4/5

[ Reply ]