Nintendo DS » Hedgehog Chronicles Trio Box Cover ← →

6,711   2 ^(?)  

Wow, BIG improvement!! Nice job. I would try and get everything to look a little smoother, though. And possibly add some kind of design behind each of the characters so the boxes don't look as plain.

Much better than your usual. Congrats. I can see the effort in this. :D

[ Reply ]

I really like this one ShadowDialga. A few things need to be changed, but I can see me faving this in the future.Maybe use that emblem (The one with the three heads) that is on Shadow's box on all of them. Try cutting the template on Silver's a bit better. And as YoshiStar said add some sort of background action behind them. Can't wait to see an updated version.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]

A big inprovement from you, I can me also faving this later on.

[ Reply ]

I thought that I might note something, the art for Sonic and Shadow are different, because they are from Sonic battle. I think that, in order for them to match more, that maybe you should use the art for Shadow and Sonic from Sonic Adventure, because the same artist drew all three of them.

The boxes are good and clean, but they are very generic, I think each box should have a more definite design.

[ Reply ]

The templates are not cut out properly. As mtirkmane said, the character art are from different games.

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]

It's... okay... but is quite choppy and all characters should be the same style, plus it's very plain.

Effort: 2.5/5

Idea: 2/5

Presentation: 1/5

Quality: 2/5

Overall: 2/5

[ Reply ]

Isn't this kind of like tleeart's idea?

...Regardless, it's a BIG improvement from your last box.

[ Reply ]

yeah, it is like tleeart's only tim's destroyed this one. xP

definitely a big improvement shadow. you're getting much better. just keep this kind of work up and you'll be respected by others soon enough. :)

[ Reply ]

Logos and templates are choppy, there is no Silver edition text, silver's icon is messed up and the characters aren't in a good style.

Not as horrible as your others, but still could be better.

2.5/5

[ Reply ]

#11, And shadow's icon.

[ Reply ]

#12, Shadow, Why don't you just settle that some people don't like some boxes.
Now don't start flaming because of me saying this but I'm waiting for a good box from you next time maybe even do The Dark Knight DVD. :)

[ Reply ]

#12, Oh, Christ, IT ISN'T A GREAT BOX! Learn to listen, it's OKAY...

[ Reply ]

#15, I think he understands now, Could we kinda get a bit more on topic because shouting ends up putting a wrong to right. O.o

[ Reply ]

XDDDDD He told himself to shutup XD

[ Reply ]

#17, LOL! Good. XDDDDDDD

[ Reply ]

You know, if you were to do things like this more often, everyon'd show you more respect.

[ Reply ]

cmon shadow, what do you expect us to say? It's a brilliant box and it should be in the hall? No people are entitled to their opinions. It's extremely average, yes it's a big improvement from your last one but that's not really saying much is it? I'm taking a leaf out of Karma's box and making it my new year's resolution to not comment on any more of your boxes.

[ Reply ]

a big improvment over your other boxes, but still not the best. I see alot of effort put into this,and that is good. However, some of the temps are cut out badly, the art styles aren't all the same, and it is a little plain, but this is an accomplishment from you. Keep it up! :)

[ Reply ]

1 hour each one?!?
Is not so big improvement. 3/5

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]

#8, I know people are entitled to their own opinion, but I am seriously wondering how you rate the effort so low. Comparing this one to his other boxes, I can definitely see an improvement. And he's put effort in the other ones, so he must have put a LOT more effort into these. I'm not so sure and can't assume, but I just have a little feeling that a lot of you guys just have it against ShadowDialga and ignore the effort put into it. Not everyone is the same, so an equal amount of effort may not have a proportional result. I'm betting ShadowDialga put more effort (in this box mainly) than I did on my Mario & Luigi one.

#20, What's wrong with you? Sure, ShadowDialga may not be able to take any more of the negative comments, but that doesn't mean you strike back by ignoring his boxes.

I'm not siding with anyone here, if it sounds like I am. Just pointing out what I'm seeing - may not be true, though. Even I'm entitled to my own opinion about you guys, though. =]

[ Reply ]

#24 I just always end up getting into arguments about it. I'll try not too though :p
Damnit! I just broke my new years resolution, ah well I guess I'll just try and do proper critiques with you XD

Edited at 1 decade ago

[ Reply ]

I'm going to favorite this, just to show you that your harder work gets you my respect. If nothing else, that should mean something to you, right?

[ Reply ]